18,000 killed needlessly a year!

To our great distress, it is currently IMPOSSIBLE to accurately count the deaths caused by medical error.

This infamous figure of 18,000 deaths in one year was announced in Parliament of Australia by Minister for Health, The Hon Carmen Lawrence, on 14 June 1995.  Then it was peer reviewed and published in The Medical Journal of Australia in November 1995. The figure is actually extrapolated from a statistically valid sample of 14,179 hospital admissions.

We believe it underestimates the horrifying magnitude of medical error. Two decades later, we are still waiting for a standardised, accurate, centralised, compulsory system for recording the death toll.  When this exists, it will expose hospital managements to public scrutiny.  Even more important, it will give the medical system the opportunity to learn from its mistakes – and prevent them.

If you think we are being alarmist, consider this: Medical error is totally ignored as a cause of death by the Australia Bureau of Statistics (ABS).  It should be at least second from the top.

18,000 deaths graph click to enlarge

 QAHCS click to enlarge 

For a comprehensive overview see:

“QAHCS: Examined OR Exposed?” 



A more recent Victorian study gives more cause for alarm

At this rate, the national tally of medical adverse events would be over 54,000 leading to 13,500 preventable deaths.

18,000 dead? 13,500 dead? Nobody knows for sure. But every study shows that the suffering and death caused by hospitals far exceed the road toll * – a national, shameful scandal.

See:  http://www.mja.com.au/public/issues/184_11_050606/ehs11107_fm.html

* ABS: Transport accidents: 1,402 deaths registered in 2008.

“Case-mix” turned out to be case-shambles

Around two-thirds of senior clinicians were of the view that government reforms have contributed to a deterioration in the quality of clinical care in their respective hospitals.

The main reasons for the decline were increased economic pressures caused by the drive for shorter lengths of stay in hospitals and increased patient throughput, a higher proportion of beds occupied by seriously ill patients and staff reductions.

Increased patient acuity, reduced patient/staff ratios, a reduction of experienced staff and not enough time for more supervision have contributed to the increased proportion of adverse events.

Increased workloads lead to less attention to detail resulting in greater opportunity for adverse incidents. Less time and more haste in planning and implementing procedures and treatments are also contributing factors to adverse events.

…Acute Health Services Under Casemix – A Case of Mixed Priorities. Tabled in Parliament of Victoria, May 1998.

18,000 errors kill     2001.02.14 Hospital errors go on the record